Health communication needs to be adapted to the needs of differing social groups, especially in times of crisis
A representative survey of 500 ultra-Orthodox Israeli adults during the COVID-19 pandemic has revealed the role that digital media can play in promoting safer behavior by increasing compliance with government health regulations
Ultra-Orthodox communities in Israel have been more affected by the COVID-19 pandemic than other segments of the Israeli population. A variety of reasons might be responsible for this. Professor Yossi David of the Department of Communication of Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz (JGU) is investigating, among other things, the role of digital media in the health and safety practices of these religious communities. As evidenced by the study now published, using new media can make a significant difference in improving compliance with government health guidelines. The study is based on a representative survey of 500 ultra-Orthodox Israeli adults conducted during the second COVID-19 wave in the fall of 2020, i.e., before vaccinations were available. „Study participants who accessed certain websites and social media were more likely to adhere to government health guidelines, such as wearing a mask. This suggests that in times of crisis digital media can promote safer behavior in authoritarian communities,“ concluded Professor Yossi David. He conducted the survey together with Dr. Baruch Shomron, a postdoctoral fellow in his group at Mainz University. The research has now been published in „New Media & Society“.
Ultra-Orthodox communities contributed significantly to the incidence of infection in Israel
The high COVID-19 mortality in Israel in 2020 can be partially explained by the disproportionate number of ultra-Orthodox community members tested positive. The Ultra-Orthodox community members are about 13 percent of Israel’s population, but they accounted for 28 to 37 percent of all COVID-19 cases. In the ultra-Orthodox population, the mortality due to COVID-19 was six times higher among the elderly generation (60 years of age and older) than among the same population in the rest of Israel during 2020. A variety of reasons have been proposed for explanation. It has been suggested that people in this group perhaps failed to comply with government COVID-19 regulations, such as the prohibition of attending weddings or funerals, while another suggestion points to cramped housing conditions and a lack of health information.
„With this in mind, we wanted to investigate how the danger posed by high COVID-19 case rates could be mitigated by information and communication technologies,“ explained Professor Yossi David. Modern technology is used far less frequently in ultra-Orthodox groups than in the rest of Israel. There are 1.2 million members of ultra-Orthodox communities in Israel leading a secluded life, following Jewish-Orthodox laws, and distancing themselves from Western influences. Rabbis oversee many aspects of daily life, including the adoption or use of new technologies. As cell phones became ever more ubiquitous in everyday life, rabbinical committees eventually approved so-called kosher devices, which allow people to make phone calls but not to access other functions such as text messaging or the Internet. The community’s traditional media – print media and radio – are also supervised by rabbis and adhere to ultra-Orthodox rules, online news websites are prohibited.
Only 47 percent of participants in the study with Internet access at home
The study conducted by JGU Israel Professor Yossi David and Baruch Shomron was based on a survey of 500 Jewish ultra-Orthodox Israelis at the height of the COVID-19 crisis in November 2020. Half of the participants were men and half were women, with an average age of 40. The interviews were conducted by the Askaria polling company, which specializes in conducting surveys among the ultra-Orthodox community in Israel.
The findings reveal that women were more likely than men to follow government health regulations, such as wearing a face mask, observing social distancing rules, or complying with hygiene measures. In addition, acceptance of COVID-19 regulations increased with age, while no association was found with socioeconomic status or level of education. The use of digital media varied: Almost all respondents, 99 percent, owned a cell phone, but 419 people or 84 percent said they used only a ‚kosher‘ device. Only 47 percent of respondents had Internet access at home – a finding consistent with data from the Israeli Central Bureau of Statistics. News websites were accessed by 20 percent, but only 8 percent read mainstream Israeli news websites. Thirteen percent use social media.
Investigating whether the use of digital media could reveal something about compliance with government health regulations, the following picture emerged: Ultra-Orthodox individuals who frequently used the Internet either for study purposes or for essential websites and apps – such as for e-banking – were more likely to comply with COVID-19 rules. In contrast, using the Internet for work, e-mail, online shopping, or other purposes has no such effect. In addition, the study found that individuals who used social media were more likely to follow COVID-19 rules than participants who did not. Finally, communications researchers David and Shomron found that reading mainstream Israeli online media contribute to the level of adhering to the government health guidelines, while ultra-Orthodox websites did not.
Health communication needs to be adapted to the needs of the population
„Health communication needs to be adapted to the needs of all segments of society, to their media habits and cultural beliefs,“ concluded Yossi David and Baruch Shomron. „In times of national and international emergencies, digital media could serve as an effective means of communicating with authoritarian and closed-off communities, including those that reject science and spread conspiracy theories, extreme right-wing groups, and conservative, insulated religious groups.“
Since October 2018, communication researcher Yossi David has held the Israel Professorship at Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz, which was established at the Department of Communication. Before coming to Mainz as the first Israel Professor in Communication Science, David worked in the field of political communication and empirical methodologies at the Hebrew University in Jerusalem.
Street scene in Jerusalem: About 25 percent of Israel’s ultra-Orthodox population lives here.
photo/©: Yossi David
https://www.ifp.uni-mainz.de/israel-professorship-in-communication-science/ – Israel Professorship in Communication Science at JGU
https://www.magazin.uni-mainz.de/9788_ENG_HTML.php – JGU Magazine: „‚We talk about one another rather than with each other'“ (11 Dec. 2018) ;
https://www.uni-mainz.de/presse/aktuell/6360_ENG_HTML.php – press release „New Israel Professorship in Communication Science at Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz“ (9 Oct. 2018)
Contact for scientific information:
Professor Dr. Yossi David
Israel Professorship in Communication Science
Department of Communication
Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz
55099 Mainz, GERMANY
phone +49 6131 39-29884
B. Shomron, Y. David, Protecting the community: How digital media promotes safer behavior during the Covid-19 pandemic in authoritarian communities—a case study of the ultra-Orthodox community in Israel, New Media & Society, 4 February 2022